20 Horror Movies That Might Not Have Been Made in Today’s Cancel Culture
In recent years, the landscape of film production and reception has changed significantly. The rise of cancel culture has brought a heightened awareness to issues of representation, sensitivity, and political correctness.
While this has led to a more inclusive and thoughtful media environment, it also means that some movies from the past would face significant backlash if they were made today. This is especially true in the horror genre, where filmmakers often pushed boundaries and explored controversial themes.
Here, we delve into 20 horror movies that, for various reasons, might not survive the scrutiny of today’s audiences.
1. “The Exorcist” (1973)
Director: William Friedkin
Plot: A mother seeks the help of two priests to save her daughter, who is possessed by a demonic entity.
Controversy: Known for its intense and graphic depiction of demonic possession, “The Exorcist” includes scenes of extreme violence, blasphemy, and a disturbing portrayal of a young girl in peril. The use of religious imagery in such a horrific context would likely provoke significant backlash from both religious communities and advocates against graphic depictions of child suffering.
2. “A Serbian Film” (2010)
Director: Srđan Spasojević
Plot: An aging porn star is lured back into the industry, only to find himself in a snuff film involving extreme sexual violence.
Controversy: Infamous for its explicit scenes of sexual violence and child exploitation, “A Serbian Film” was banned in multiple countries and heavily censored in others. The extreme content would not align with today’s stricter regulations and heightened sensitivity towards sexual violence and exploitation.
3. “I Spit on Your Grave” (1978)
Director: Meir Zarchi
Plot: A woman seeks brutal revenge on the men who sexually assaulted her.
Controversy: The film’s graphic depictions of sexual assault and its subsequent portrayal of violent revenge would face severe criticism for glorifying and trivialising sexual violence. Modern audiences are more attuned to the portrayal of sexual violence in media, making such content largely unacceptable.
4. “Cannibal Holocaust” (1980)
Director: Ruggero Deodato
Plot: A rescue mission uncovers the gruesome fate of a documentary crew who encountered a tribe of cannibals.
Controversy: Featuring real animal killings and extreme violence, “Cannibal Holocaust” was one of the most controversial films ever made. Its graphic content and unethical treatment of animals would not be tolerated today, leading to its likely cancellation.
5. “The Texas Chainsaw Massacre” (1974)
Director: Tobe Hooper
Plot: A group of friends falls victim to a family of cannibals in rural Texas.
Controversy: The film’s brutal violence and depiction of cannibalism would likely face significant backlash today. The portrayal of mentally ill characters as violent cannibals could also be considered highly problematic by modern standards.
6. “The Human Centipede” (2009)
Director: Tom Six
Plot: A mad scientist surgically connects three people to create a human centipede.
Controversy: The film’s grotesque premise and explicit surgical scenes push the boundaries of taste and decency. The dehumanising treatment of its characters would be considered deeply offensive and likely lead to calls for censorship.
7. “Child’s Play” (1988)
Director: Tom Holland
Plot: A possessed doll named Chucky wreaks havoc after being bought as a child’s birthday gift.
Controversy: The portrayal of a child’s toy turning into a homicidal maniac could be seen as too disturbing for today’s audiences. Additionally, the graphic violence involving a child’s toy might face significant criticism from parental groups and child advocacy organisations.
8. “Last House on the Left” (1972)
Director: Wes Craven
Plot: Two teenage girls are kidnapped and brutalised by a gang of escaped convicts.
Controversy: With its intense scenes of sexual violence and torture, “Last House on the Left” would undoubtedly be criticised for its graphic content and perceived exploitation of women. The film’s brutal nature would not sit well with today’s more sensitive and socially conscious audiences.
9. “Faces of Death” (1978)
Director: John Alan Schwartz
Plot: A compilation of real and staged footage depicting death and violence.
Controversy: Known for its shock value, “Faces of Death” mixes real and fake footage of death and violence. The ethical concerns and graphic content would make such a film highly controversial and likely banned in today’s media environment.
10. “Silent Night, Deadly Night” (1984)
Director: Charles E. Sellier Jr.
Plot: A young man, traumatised by the murder of his parents by a man dressed as Santa Claus, becomes a killer dressed in a Santa suit.
Controversy: The film faced significant backlash upon release for its depiction of Santa Claus as a murderer. Today, the combination of holiday imagery and graphic violence would likely face even more intense criticism.
11. “Martyrs” (2008)
Director: Pascal Laugier
Plot: A woman seeks revenge on those who imprisoned and tortured her as a child.
Controversy: The extreme violence and psychological torture depicted in “Martyrs” push the limits of horror. The graphic content and themes of religious martyrdom would likely be considered too extreme for today’s audiences.
12. “The Hills Have Eyes” (1977)
Director: Wes Craven
Plot: A family on a road trip becomes stranded and is attacked by a clan of cannibalistic mutants.
Controversy: The portrayal of mutants as violent and savage could be seen as insensitive and problematic. The graphic violence and sexual assault depicted in the film would also face significant scrutiny.
13. “Maniac” (1980)
Director: William Lustig
Plot: A disturbed man stalks and kills women in New York City.
Controversy: The graphic violence, particularly against women, and the film’s depiction of mental illness as a cause for extreme violence would be heavily criticised in today’s cultural climate. The film’s explicit content would likely face severe backlash.
14. “Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer” (1986)
Director: John McNaughton
Plot: A disturbing look into the life of a serial killer.
Controversy: The film’s realistic and unflinching portrayal of violence, including sexual assault and murder, would be considered highly problematic. The glorification of the serial killer as a central character could also draw significant criticism.
15. “Audition” (1999)
Director: Takashi Miike
Plot: A widower’s search for a new wife through a fake audition leads to horrifying consequences.
Controversy: The film’s graphic torture scenes and its portrayal of a woman as a sadistic torturer could be seen as misogynistic. The extreme violence and psychological horror would likely be deemed too intense for contemporary audiences.
16. “The Woman” (2011)
Director: Lucky McKee
Plot: A man captures and attempts to “civilise” a feral woman, with horrific results.
Controversy: The themes of captivity and torture, along with the depiction of the feral woman, would likely be criticized for misogyny and exploitation. The graphic violence and disturbing content would make it highly controversial.
17. “Dead Alive” (1992)
Director: Peter Jackson
Plot: A man’s mother is bitten by a Sumatran rat-monkey, turning her into a zombie and unleashing a zombie apocalypse.
Controversy: Known for its over-the-top gore and violence, “Dead Alive” (also known as “Braindead”) would face criticism for its extreme and graphic content. The combination of horror and comedy might not sit well with modern audiences sensitive to depictions of extreme violence.
18. “Hostel” (2005)
Director: Eli Roth
Plot: Backpackers are lured into a hostel where they are sold to wealthy clients for torture and murder.
Controversy: The graphic depictions of torture and the film’s perceived xenophobia would make it highly controversial today. The portrayal of Eastern Europeans as sadistic torturers could be seen as offensive and problematic.
19. “The Green Inferno” (2013)
Director: Eli Roth
Plot: Activists are captured by a cannibalistic tribe in the Amazon rainforest.
Controversy: The depiction of indigenous people as savage cannibals would be considered deeply offensive and racist. The graphic violence and portrayal of the tribe would likely face severe backlash.
20. “The House That Jack Built” (2018)
Director: Lars von Trier
Plot: A serial killer recounts his murders in gruesome detail.
Controversy: The film’s explicit depictions of violence, including against women and children, and its portrayal of the serial killer as a complex character would be highly controversial. The graphic content and themes would likely provoke significant criticism.
Conclusion
The horror genre has long been a space for filmmakers to explore the darkest aspects of human nature and push the boundaries of what is acceptable on screen.
However, in today’s cultural climate, many of these films would face intense scrutiny and backlash. While some might argue that this represents a loss of artistic freedom
Image Copyright: All Images on this page remain the property of their respective owners. Credit is given wherever possible. If you are the owner of an image featured and have not been credited, please let us know, we are happy to remove or credit any offending image.
© Colin Lawson Books