The “Mary Sue” Character and the Art of Self-Insertion: When Writers Can’t Help Themselves
We’ve all been there. You’re deep into the latest fantasy novel, and out of nowhere, a character shows up who is flawless, inexplicably powerful, and, well… a little too perfect. You know the one. This character can do no wrong, everyone loves them, and their abilities seem to break all the laws of logic. Congratulations! You’ve just met a Mary Sue (or a Gary Stu for the guys). And trust me, it’s as inevitable as a plot twist in a soap opera.
But where does this peculiar species of character come from? Why do some writers—often subconsciously—infuse themselves into their stories in such a, shall we say, flawless way?
Welcome to the world of self-insertion, where fiction meets daydreaming and Mary Sue reigns supreme.
So, What Exactly is a Mary Sue?
A Mary Sue is the character who seems to have wandered off the pages of a fanfiction forum straight into your favourite story. They are often an idealised version of the writer themselves: perfect in looks, talent, and temperament.
These characters rarely face any true hardship (or when they do, they heroically overcome it without breaking a sweat), and somehow, everyone around them is either in awe or falls in love at first sight. It’s as if the laws of the universe are bending to ensure their comfort.
Think of a character who is so stunningly awesome that even dragons take a break from torching villages just to compliment their hair. Yep, that’s our Mary Sue.
Famous Examples of Mary Sues in Popular Stories
Some of these Mary Sues are so sneaky that they slip by without us even noticing, while others are glaring examples of too much perfection. Here are a few notable characters from famous stories that tend to fall into Mary Sue territory.
Rey from Star Wars: The Sequel Trilogy
Ah, Rey. When we first met her in The Force Awakens, she was a seemingly ordinary scavenger living on the desolate planet of Jakku. But as the trilogy unfolded, she quickly mastered the Force, lightsaber combat, and piloting the Millennium Falcon without any formal training.
Rey’s almost immediate proficiency in these skills left many fans scratching their heads. While she’s a compelling character in many ways, her meteoric rise in abilities has led some to dub her a Mary Sue.
Despite her lack of backstory and mentorship, Rey manages to best seasoned Force users and comes across as a bit too perfect in her role as the galaxy’s new hope. Her struggles seem more external than internal, which makes her less relatable than, say, Luke Skywalker, who had to overcome deep self-doubt, failure, and defeat along the way.
Bella Swan from Twilight
If Mary Sue had a bestie, it would be Bella Swan. Bella, the moody but mysteriously alluring high school girl from Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight series, might seem average, but everyone in her new town is instantly drawn to her. Vampires and werewolves alike fall in love with Bella at first sight, and she becomes the center of a supernatural love triangle.
Despite her lack of remarkable talents or personality quirks (besides biting her lip), she’s portrayed as an irresistible enigma. As the series progresses, Bella remains perfect in the eyes of the male characters around her, and even when she does encounter obstacles, she overcomes them without much personal growth or internal struggle.
Eragon from The Inheritance Cycle
At first glance, Eragon seems like the classic hero’s journey story. A young farm boy finds a dragon egg, and his life is forever changed. But as the story unfolds, Eragon becomes a little too good at everything. He’s a natural dragon rider, learns magic almost instantly, and grows into an unstoppable force with very little struggle.
Much like Rey, Eragon has some internal dilemmas, but his ability to master nearly every skill he touches can come off as a bit too convenient. His heroic arc lacks some of the gritty, realistic setbacks that make similar characters more relatable.
Captain Marvel from the MCU
When Carol Danvers, aka Captain Marvel, made her debut in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), she brought with her immense power—so much so that she was instantly considered one of the strongest characters in the MCU. While that’s not necessarily a problem, her lack of weaknesses (both emotionally and physically) put her squarely in Mary Sue territory for many fans.
Her character development remains somewhat stagnant compared to other Marvel heroes who grapple with internal flaws or complex relationships. While she has an engaging backstory, by the time we meet her in Captain Marvel, she’s so invulnerable that her character arc feels more like a straight line than the traditional hero’s journey.
The Origins of Mary Sue
The term “Mary Sue” was originally coined in the realm of fanfiction, but this phenomenon has existed much longer. The name itself comes from a satirical 1973 Star Trek fanfic where the character Lt. Mary Sue, a 15-year-old prodigy, basically outshines the entire Enterprise crew with her sheer brilliance. And thus, a trope was born.
From fantasy to sci-fi and romance, these characters quickly invaded every genre, leaving behind a trail of overpowered, often cringe-worthy protagonists.
But the Mary Sue isn’t just some accident that happens when writers forget to add conflict. It’s rooted in something much deeper—the art of self-insertion.
Self-Insertion: The Writer’s Wish Fulfilment Playground
Self-insertion is the not-so-secret guilty pleasure of many writers. It’s the act of putting oneself into a story, either directly or through an idealized avatar. And let’s be real—who doesn’t want to live in their own epic fantasy world? Who wouldn’t want to be the heroic knight, the suave detective, or the chosen one who defeats the ultimate evil while looking impossibly cool?
But when does it go wrong? When self-insertion slips into Mary Sue territory, things start to unravel faster than the villain’s evil plan at the end of a Disney movie.
Here’s why: Relatability. Flawed characters are human. They make mistakes, have weaknesses, and (gasp!) even lose battles. This makes them feel real. A Mary Sue, on the other hand, breezes through challenges like they’ve read the script. Their flawlessness creates distance between the reader and the character. It’s fun for the writer to imagine themselves as untouchable, but the reader? They’re left rolling their eyes, waiting for something interesting to happen.
The Art of Self-Insertion Done Right
So, how does a writer avoid the pitfalls of the Mary Sue while still indulging in a little creative self-fantasy? Here are some tips to keep your self-insert character from hogging the spotlight:
1. Give Them Flaws (Real Ones!)
No one is perfect. Not you, not me, not even that ridiculously charming, brilliant, and athletic character you just introduced. The best characters have flaws that make them relatable.
Maybe your self-insert character has a crippling fear of rejection, or they’re terrible at public speaking. Perhaps they’re stubborn, impulsive, or just plain bad at cooking. Whatever it is, make sure it’s something that challenges them in a meaningful way.
2. Let Them Fail
Failures make victories sweeter. It’s tempting to make your self-insert character the ultimate winner, but nothing keeps readers on the edge of their seat like a good ol’ fashioned struggle.
Let your character lose a fight, mess up a plan, or make a huge mistake. That’s where growth happens—and where readers get invested.
3. Tone Down the Superpowers
Sure, it’s fun to imagine yourself wielding godlike powers, but unless you’re writing actual gods, tone it down a bit. Give your character limits. Even superheroes have weaknesses.
Maybe your protagonist has incredible strength, but they get easily distracted. Or perhaps they’re a genius inventor but terrible at communicating their ideas. Finding that balance keeps things interesting.
4. Share the Spotlight
Your self-insert character doesn’t need to solve every problem or save the day in every scene. Let the supporting cast shine.
Allow other characters to have their own skills and moments of glory. After all, even Frodo had Sam to carry him up Mount Doom.
Embrace the Mary Sue… Just Keep Her in Check
In conclusion, the Mary Sue isn’t some literary crime that deserves endless ridicule. But when she (or he) starts to take over, it can dilute the strength of your story. Self-insertion, when done carefully, can be an exciting and meaningful exercise in self-expression.
Just remember: even the most heroic characters need flaws, struggles, and a good dose of humility to keep them grounded.
So go ahead, write that character who wields a sword made of starlight, can charm the pants off a dragon, and is the last hope for humanity—just make sure they trip over their cape once in a while.
And if that fails, well, we’ll all still be here, waiting to welcome the next Mary Sue into the hall of literary fame.
Image Copyright: All Images on this page remain the property of their respective owners. Credit is given wherever possible. If you are the owner of an image featured and have not been credited, please let us know, we are happy to remove or credit any offending image.
© Colin Lawson Books